Congrats Cincy

[keln]

On a big win for Miami. And boy did they do it in style...



Maybe you've been right all year about firing Golden. Their first game after he's canned and they come out to win.

(Updated for better video)

[victor2111]

Crazy. Wow. The past few years have been some crazy finishes in CFB

This game
Michigan - Michigan state
Auburn - Bama
GT - FSU

[cwerph]

Terry Porter approves of these "calls" (or lack thereof).

[cwerph]

Better quality.

[mikeytbuckeyes]

Sounded like the ACC was going to review it today and could possibly reverse the call saying that the runner was down. They could do this since there was no more time on the clock and no "what if's" remaining. Therefore, they would award Duke the win of they choose to reverse the call.
I have a hard time seeing them do that as it would be very bad PR for the ACC as it would be admitting their officials suck. If they just let it go everyone would forget about it, the ACC could spin it as excitement within the conference, and they save face.

[Deleted]

I dont understand the penalty part. I didn't think they could overturn a penalty upon review.

[Deleted]

Thanks! And if they over turn, Miami needs to leave the ACC. Miami had 194 penalty yarfs to Duke's 41, and Duke got three calls go their way on the last drive...two PI's and I do not think they broke the plane on their TD either

[keln]

Nov 1, 2015 7:23:10 GMT -5 mikeytbuckeyes said:

Sounded like the ACC was going to review it today and could possibly reverse the call saying that the runner was down. They could do this since there was no more time on the clock and no "what if's" remaining. Therefore, they would award Duke the win of they choose to reverse the call.
I have a hard time seeing them do that as it would be very bad PR for the ACC as it would be admitting their officials suck. If they just let it go everyone would forget about it, the ACC could spin it as excitement within the conference, and they save face.

I agree. The ACC would be nuts to overturn this. I watched that part where the guy is going down and laterals it several times and it looks like one of those "not enough evidence to overturn" type of plays that officials just end up letting stand as called on the field. There might not be as much outrage towards the ACC if they did overturn this if it were a definite case of a player being down and the officials just not catching it, but if that had happened everyone and their brother would have caught it and been giving this win an asterisk, especially since the officials reviewed the play at the end of the game and still let it stand.

[Deleted]

Officials suspended for 2 games after they botched the final play. They only made 4 mistakes on one play. LOL

www.theacc.com/news/acc-announces-11-01-2015

[TH1Bucks]

Oct 31, 2015 22:57:34 GMT -5 cwerph said:

Terry Porter approves of these "calls" (or lack thereof).

ROFL,,,,, What a GREAT Ref !!!!!! Sorry Cinci !

[Deleted]

Oh they missed some calls on that play, but that play is not needed If they do not screw Miami three times in one drive. Artie Burns, whose mother just passed Wednesday, made a hell of a pick that would have ended the game....and they called PI. I know I am biased, but it was not even close. He went over the guy's shoulder, but he had the ball before contact was made. Then they called one that may have been even worse on a 3rd and 10....even the WR just turned to run back to the huddle, as the ball was over thrown by 20 yards. So yes, these refs sucked, but we had 194 penalty yards to their 41....so these Duke fans can shove it

[keln]

Nov 1, 2015 18:04:54 GMT -5 @cincycanesfan said:

Oh they missed some calls on that play, but that play is not needed If they do not screw Miami three times in one drive. Artie Burns, whose mother just passed Wednesday, made a hell of a pick that would have ended the game....and they called PI. I know I am biased, but it was not even close. He went over the guy's shoulder, but he had the ball before contact was made. Then they called one that may have been even worse on a 3rd and 10....even the WR just turned to run back to the huddle, as the ball was over thrown by 20 yards. So yes, these refs sucked, but we had 194 penalty yards to their 41....so these Duke fans can shove it

I'll have to take your word for it, but if this is true then that alone means the ACC can't really pick on poor officiating in one play and ignore the others and use that as justification to reverse the outcome of the game. Suspend the officials for a couple games and move on.

[cwerph]

Nov 1, 2015 20:48:28 GMT -5 keln said:

Nov 1, 2015 18:04:54 GMT -5 @cincycanesfan said:

Oh they missed some calls on that play, but that play is not needed If they do not screw Miami three times in one drive. Artie Burns, whose mother just passed Wednesday, made a hell of a pick that would have ended the game....and they called PI. I know I am biased, but it was not even close. He went over the guy's shoulder, but he had the ball before contact was made. Then they called one that may have been even worse on a 3rd and 10....even the WR just turned to run back to the huddle, as the ball was over thrown by 20 yards. So yes, these refs sucked, but we had 194 penalty yards to their 41....so these Duke fans can shove it

I'll have to take your word for it, but if this is true then that alone means the ACC can't really pick on poor officiating in one play and ignore the others and use that as justification to reverse the outcome of the game. Suspend the officials for a couple games and move on.

This is exactly why they can't change the outcome of the game no matter how bad the officiating was on the last play.

[Deleted]

Nov 1, 2015 10:56:26 GMT -5 @cincycanesfan said:

Thanks! And if they over turn, Miami needs to leave the ACC. Miami had 194 penalty yarfs to Duke's 41, and Duke got three calls go their way on the last drive...two PI's and I do not think they broke the plane on their TD either

Enjoy it. My boss was there and will be pissed all week.

[Deleted]

Here is my bosses take on it. He saw the guy's knee hit the ground and was not worried, then the TD. Miami stormed the field and were on the field before the play ended. When it went to review, the Miami players went nuts. They were throwing helmets and in the ref's face. Heck the coach was on the field. It was similar to a mini riot if you were there. He believes the Refs were scared and intimidated and wanted to get out of there.

Boss did credit Galloway and another former tOSU player for being the first to stand up for Duke. Galloway said this will not go down as a great ending, just a very bad called ending to a game.